Create account
Cover of Supernatural

Similar games

Games like Supernatural

2024PC62 % positive8.79 €

You step into the shoes of detective Wyatt, who searches a haunted house for a missing housemaid. Its appeal lies in the creeping atmosphere, where you piece together clues and treat every shadow with suspicion.

  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative
＋ Combine with my games
Buy from 8.79 €
Steam

More in these topics: Horror games

The closest matches for Supernatural are Simulacra, Black Mirror II: Reigning Evil and Call of Cthulhu. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Supernatural special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

10 games with a similar feel, sorted by match · How is this calculated?

Show games from the same series

Best match

Simulacra

93 %Match

2017PCPlayStationXboxNintendo SwitchSteam Deck verified92 % positive4.59 €

Brings what grabs you about Supernatural: dread and tension, a strong story as well as a dark atmosphere.

You dig through a missing woman's smartphone, reading messages, using apps and watching videos, to piece together a creepy mystery. A short, story-driven horror experience told through found-footage-style screen interaction.

Similar games →
Buy from 4.59 €
Steam

Call of Cthulhu

Dread and tension

As shell-shocked private eye Edward Pierce you investigate a mysterious death on a grim whaling island and slide steadily into Lovecraftian madness. Investigation, dialogue skills and your fraying sanity shape how the story ends.

Mad Father

Dread and tension

A short RPG Maker horror adventure in which you play Aya, uncovering the dark secrets of her mad doctor father inside a mansion. Puzzles, chase sequences and multiple endings deliver a macabre yet emotional story.

Dead Secret

Dread and tension

A first-person horror mystery set in 1960s Kansas where you investigate a reclusive professor's death by searching his house and solving puzzles, while a threat closes in.

Phantasmagoria

Dread and tension

A 1990s point-and-click horror adventure with live-action video footage: as Adrienne you explore a sinister mansion and uncover its dark secret. Notorious for its graphic scenes and full-motion-video style.

Stigmatized Property

Accessible and relaxed

In Stigmatized Property you investigate haunted Japanese apartments whose suspiciously cheap rents hide a dark secret. The tension comes from slowly piecing together clues until you uncover what really haunts each room.

Blair Witch

Dread and tension

A psychological horror game where you play an ex-soldier searching a cursed forest with your dog Bullet. The woods warp space and perception, and your dog is your key companion against fear and madness.

Prognostic

Dread and tension

A supernatural horror detective adventure in which an orphan inherits a fortune-teller's legacy and works as a medium to solve puzzles and cases. Mystery, creeping dread and investigation take center stage.

Feedback