Cover of Supernatural

Similar games

Games like Supernatural

2024PC62 % positive8.79 €

You step into the shoes of detective Wyatt, who searches a haunted house for a missing housemaid. Its appeal lies in the creeping atmosphere, where you piece together clues and treat every shadow with suspicion.

  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative

The closest matches for Supernatural are Black Mirror II: Reigning Evil, Simulacra and Call of Cthulhu. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Supernatural special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

10 games with a similar feel, sorted by match

Show games from the same series

Best match

Black Mirror II: Reigning Evil

94 %Match

2009PC91 % positive9.99 €

  • Dread and tension
  • Dark, serious atmosphere
  • Strong, story-driven narrative

A classic point-and-click horror adventure set in the 1990s, where you unravel a dark family mystery through inventory and dialogue puzzles. Its story and creepy atmosphere take center stage.

Simulacra

Dread and tension

You dig through a missing woman's smartphone, reading messages, using apps and watching videos, to piece together a creepy mystery. A short, story-driven horror experience told through found-footage-style screen interaction.

Call of Cthulhu

Dread and tension

As shell-shocked private eye Edward Pierce you investigate a mysterious death on a grim whaling island and slide steadily into Lovecraftian madness. Investigation, dialogue skills and your fraying sanity shape how the story ends.

Dead Secret

Dread and tension

A first-person horror mystery set in 1960s Kansas where you investigate a reclusive professor's death by searching his house and solving puzzles, while a threat closes in.

Mad Father

Dread and tension

A short RPG Maker horror adventure in which you play Aya, uncovering the dark secrets of her mad doctor father inside a mansion. Puzzles, chase sequences and multiple endings deliver a macabre yet emotional story.

Phantasmagoria

Dread and tension

A 1990s point-and-click horror adventure with live-action video footage: as Adrienne you explore a sinister mansion and uncover its dark secret. Notorious for its graphic scenes and full-motion-video style.

Blair Witch

Dread and tension

A psychological horror game where you play an ex-soldier searching a cursed forest with your dog Bullet. The woods warp space and perception, and your dog is your key companion against fear and madness.

Stigmatized Property

Accessible and relaxed

In Stigmatized Property you investigate haunted Japanese apartments whose suspiciously cheap rents hide a dark secret. The tension comes from slowly piecing together clues until you uncover what really haunts each room.

The Cabin Factory

Accessible and relaxed

You work as an inspector at a factory that produces cabins, judging whether each one is haunted. The game is about careful observation, spotting anomalies and knowing when to run.

Feedback