Similar games

Games like The Innsmouth Case

2020PCPlayStationXboxNintendo Switch67 % positive12.49 €

A text-based choose-your-own-adventure in the spirit of H.P. Lovecraft, where you investigate the eerie town of Innsmouth, blending cosmic horror with dark humor. Your choices steer the story toward different outcomes.

Choices with consequences
Strong, story-driven narrative
Lots of humour
Dark, serious atmosphere

＋ Combine with my games

More in these topics: Story-driven games Games with meaningful choices

The closest matches for The Innsmouth Case are Nighthawks, Sucker for Love: Date to Die For and Scarlet Hollow. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes The Innsmouth Case special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

Best match

Nighthawks

92 %Match

2026PCSteam Deck playable−15 % ~~16.79 €~~ 14.27 €

Choices with consequences
Strong, story-driven narrative
Dark, serious atmosphere

A story-driven urban fantasy RPG from Wadjet Eye Games and writer Richard Cobbett that blends narrative with an undead life-simulation. Managing your time, learning skills and making decisions shape your path through a mysterious city.

Similar games →

Sucker for Love: Date to Die For

Lots of humour

A Lovecraftian horror dating sim where you evade cultists and survive rituals while romancing eldritch beings. The tone is tongue-in-cheek, with plenty of humor and multiple endings.

Scarlet Hollow

Dark, serious atmosphere

A story-driven horror visual novel set in a North Carolina mining town, where your choices and relationships with the locals decide who survives. Folk-horror dread, a creeping mystery and a hand-drawn look define the experience.

The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

Dark, serious atmosphere

A dark, story-driven RPG Maker horror about two siblings starving in a quarantined apartment. Your choices lead to disturbing, macabre and often darkly funny turns across many endings.

Overboard!

Lots of humour

You play the murderer aboard a 1935 ocean liner and must cover up your crime. Branching choices and repeated playthroughs reveal many different endings in this stylish inverted mystery.

Tokyo Dark

Dark, serious atmosphere

A dark anime-styled point-and-click horror adventure where you play Detective Itou investigating her partner's disappearance in Tokyo. Your choices and mental state shape available options and lead to multiple endings.

Mask of the Rose

Accessible and relaxed

A Failbetter Games visual novel set in the stolen city of Fallen London, where you pursue romance while untangling a murder. Your choices shape relationships and how the story ends.

Red Embrace: Hollywood

Accessible and relaxed

An erotic-leaning visual novel set in 1996 Los Angeles, where you play a newly turned vampire finding your way through a dark underworld. Your choices shape how you survive in vampire society.

Slay the Princess

Dark, serious atmosphere

A psychological horror visual novel where you are sent to slay a princess in a cabin while a cast of voices in your head keeps commenting. Every choice sends the story spiraling into new branches, and the hand-penciled art and superb voice acting make each loop eerie and surprising.

Death and Taxes

Lots of humour

You play the Grim Reaper stuck in an office job, deciding each day who lives or dies. A humorous, narrative-driven visual novel and choice game with a stylish 2D look and a mystery about your own origins.