Similar games

Games like Sucker for Love: First Date

2022PCNintendo SwitchSteam Deck playable98 % positive8.19 €

You court eldritch horrors through a series of twisted dates, performing rituals and picking dialogue choices that decide how far things go. Its dark humor and absurd romance keep the Lovecraftian dread entertaining.

Choices with consequences
Lots of humour
Strong, story-driven narrative
Distinctive, stylised art style

＋ Combine with my games

More in these topics: Story-driven games Games with meaningful choices Funny games Games with unique art styles

The closest matches for Sucker for Love: First Date are Slay the Princess, Vampire Therapist and Speed Dating for Ghosts. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Sucker for Love: First Date special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

Best match

Slay the Princess

94 %Match

2023PCSteam Deck verified97 % positive−60 % ~~16.99 €~~ 6.79 €

Choices with consequences
Strong, story-driven narrative
Distinctive, stylised art style

A psychological horror visual novel where you are sent to slay a princess in a cabin while a cast of voices in your head keeps commenting. Every choice sends the story spiraling into new branches, and the hand-penciled art and superb voice acting make each loop eerie and surprising.

Similar games →

Vampire Therapist

Choices with consequences

You play a therapist for vampires, talking through their quirky undead troubles using real cognitive behavioral therapy ideas. A funny, dialogue-driven visual novel with a sincere emotional core.

Speed Dating for Ghosts

Fantasy setting

You chat your way through branching speed dates with phantoms, wraiths, and poltergeists, where every hard choice shapes how each encounter turns out. It blends quirky humor with light spooky atmosphere in a visual-novel style packed with offbeat characters.

Hatoful Boyfriend

Choices with consequences

An absurd pigeon high-school dating sim where you are the only human among cooing classmates. Behind the comedy lie surprisingly dark twists and many branching endings.

Death and Taxes

Choices with consequences

You play the Grim Reaper stuck in an office job, deciding each day who lives or dies. A humorous, narrative-driven visual novel and choice game with a stylish 2D look and a mystery about your own origins.

Hooked on You: A Dead by Daylight Dating Sim

Choices with consequences

A tongue-in-cheek dating sim where you woo four Dead by Daylight killers on a remote island. Romance, dark humor and sinister twists play out through dialogue and choices that lead to different endings.

Little Misfortune

Distinctive, stylised art style

A short, dark story adventure about a little girl chasing a terrible secret through a colorful fairy-tale world of oddball characters. The contrast between cute visuals, black humor and heavy themes is what makes it memorable.

The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

Choices with consequences

A dark, story-driven RPG Maker horror about two siblings starving in a quarantined apartment. Your choices lead to disturbing, macabre and often darkly funny turns across many endings.

Needy Streamer Overload

Distinctive, stylised art style

You manage the daily life of streamer Ame, scheduling streams and time slots while trying to keep her fragile mental state in check. Behind the colorful internet-culture look lies a dark story about dependency, with many different endings.

Find Love or Die Trying

Choices with consequences

You are a contestant on a deadly dating show where singles on a tropical island must charm their way out alive. This visual novel leans into absurd comedy and branching dialogue, where your choices decide whether you win someone's heart or lose your life.