Similar games
A devil-run arcade machine turns out to be a meta puzzle-horror adventure that keeps breaking its own rules and toying with your expectations. With dark humor, hacking-style puzzles and clever twists, it is short but memorable.
What defines Pony Island:
More in these topics: Puzzle games Horror games
The closest matches for Pony Island are Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes, The Franz Kafka Videogame and Rusty Lake: Roots. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Pony Island special – the reasons are listed right on each game.
94 %
Best match
A hand-drawn point-and-click adventure about Lilli, a seemingly perfect convent schoolgirl, mixing macabre black humor and quirky puzzles with a surprisingly dark story.
93 % 6.99 €
Distinctive, stylised art style
A surreal point-and-click puzzle adventure inspired by Franz Kafka's writing. As K., you travel through an absurd, unpredictable world full of odd encounters and quirky puzzles.
93 % 3.99 €
Strong, story-driven narrative
A dark point-and-click puzzle game where you grow the Vanderboom family tree across generations. Bizarre, macabre puzzles and an eerie atmosphere tell the story almost without words.
92 % 1.99 €
Distinctive, stylised art style
A macabre point-and-click puzzle game in which you play a hotel chef serving odd guests through clever, twisted puzzles. Its surreal, eerie atmosphere and cryptic Rusty Lake lore make it stand out.
92 % 3.99 €
Distinctive, stylised art style
An eerie point-and-click puzzle adventure on a remote island where the ten biblical plagues torment your family. Bizarre rituals, a dark atmosphere and surreal art make it classic Rusty Lake.
92 % 24.99 €
Strong, story-driven narrative
A dark puzzle-platformer by Swery in which J.J. is repeatedly mutilated and uses those very states to solve puzzles. Behind it lies a disturbing, emotional tale about guilt, loss and self-discovery.
92 % free
Linear, curated structure
A short, eerie point-and-click puzzle adventure set in the Rusty Lake universe: as Detective Dale Vandermeer you solve puzzles across two intertwined realities and slowly piece together a strange mystery.
91 % 14.99 €
Lots of humour
A classic LucasArts-style point-and-click adventure in which Edna escapes from a psychiatric hospital together with her talking stuffed rabbit Harvey. Dark humor, quirky characters and clever inventory puzzles define the experience.
91 %
Linear, curated structure
A short, eerie point-and-click puzzle adventure set in the surreal Rusty Lake universe, where you solve cryptic puzzles in a sinister cave and piece together the unsettling lore bit by bit.
91 % 19.50 €
Lots of humour
A deduction-driven detective puzzler where you solve 20 bizarre crime scenes in 1970s America by gathering clues, identifying people and piecing together events yourself. There is no hand-holding, only your own logic and observation.