Similar games

Games like Fears to Fathom: Scratch Creek

2026PCSteam Deck playable75 % positive8.15 €

You follow Tessa and Marcus through an eerie story that mirrors an episode of the Fears to Fathom horror series, and your decisions shape how their experience unfolds and ends.

Dread and tension
Choices with consequences
Dark, serious atmosphere
Strong, story-driven narrative

＋ Combine with my games

More in these topics: Games with meaningful choices Horror games

The closest matches for Fears to Fathom: Scratch Creek are The Closing Shift, Stay and Homicipher. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes Fears to Fathom: Scratch Creek special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

Best match

The Closing Shift

90 %Match

2022PC88 % positive5.89 €

Dread and tension
Dark, serious atmosphere
Strong, story-driven narrative

A short Japanese-style indie horror game in which you play a young woman working a late closing shift as eerie events unfold. Tension comes from atmosphere and mundane routine that gradually turns sinister.

Similar games →

Stay

Choices with consequences

You talk with an abducted man trapped in an abandoned house, trying to help him through text conversation and light puzzles. Your choices and the time you take shape multiple endings in this tense, emotional tale.

Homicipher

Dread and tension

You crack an alien language to find your way out of a strange world full of unsettling men. Along the way, a quiet, unexpected romance begins to take hold.

The Price of Flesh

Choices with consequences

A hand-drawn survival horror told as an interactive story, where your decisions lead you to one of about 50 endings. It offers plenty of full-screen artwork and optional adult content.

D

Dread and tension

An early interactive horror movie from Warp: as Laura you explore a creepy hospital in first person, solving puzzles to uncover why your father went on a killing spree. Its pre-rendered CGI cutscenes and disturbing themes like cannibalism made it infamous.

Welcome to the Game II

Dread and tension

A horror puzzle game where you play a reporter delving into the deep web and a trap-filled building to help a woman in danger. Puzzles, surveillance and survival pressure create a tense, unsettling experience.

Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location

Dread and tension

A story-heavy entry in the horror series: as a technician in an underground facility you face short, tense nights with varied tasks rather than just watching cameras. The dark tale of Circus Baby and the animatronics drives the experience.

At Dead of Night

Choices with consequences

A horror game blending live-action footage with game segments, where you play Maya hiding from a psychopath in a remote hotel while trying to free your captive friends. It mixes interactive film, stealth and investigation into a low-budget horror movie experience.

Do Not Feed the Monkeys

Choices with consequences

You join a secret club that spies on strangers through surveillance cameras and decide whether and how to interfere in their lives. You also have to pay rent and buy food, which makes every moral choice harder.

Captive

Dread and tension

You wake up injured and with no memory in an unknown cell and must find a way out. A dark indie adventure mixing horror atmosphere, puzzles and survival decisions.