Similar games

Games like BlackBay Asylum

2014PC57 % positive

You play a confused inmate who slips out of his cell and explores a grim asylum. Puzzles, horror and a touch of dark humor drive your search for the truth behind what is happening.

Puzzles and brain teasers
Dark, serious atmosphere
Strong, story-driven narrative

＋ Combine with my games

More in these topics: Puzzle games Horror games

The closest matches for BlackBay Asylum are Post Mortem, Is This Game Trying to Kill Me? and Dark Fall. Each of these 10 games shares something of what makes BlackBay Asylum special – the reasons are listed right on each game.

Best match

Post Mortem

94 %Match

2002PCSteam Deck verified56 % positive7.99 €

Puzzles and brain teasers
Dark, serious atmosphere
Strong, story-driven narrative

A dark point-and-click thriller set in Paris, where you play a former detective with clairvoyant visions hunting a killer tied to occult rituals. Puzzles and interrogations drive a dense conspiracy story.

Similar games →

Is This Game Trying to Kill Me?

Puzzles and brain teasers

A first-person horror puzzle game where you are trapped in a forest cabin and play a computer game whose traps bleed into reality. The link between the two layers drives clever puzzles and tension.

Dark Fall

Dark, serious atmosphere

A Myst-style horror adventure set in an abandoned, haunted hotel. You search for your missing brother, solve puzzles, and are unsettled by a deeply eerie soundscape.

Still Life 2

Dark, serious atmosphere

A grim point-and-click crime thriller in which you play FBI agent Victoria McPherson hunting the East Coast Torturer serial killer, solving puzzles and gathering clues to uncover who is behind Mr. X.

In Fear I Trust

Dark, serious atmosphere

You wake up as Patient #17 with no memory inside a decaying Soviet-era facility, solving puzzles and piecing together notes to uncover the truth. A grim first-person psychological horror adventure focused on atmosphere and brainteasers.

The Grandfather

Puzzles and brain teasers

A short point-and-click puzzle game with a horror atmosphere, where you explore the grim, sorrowful story of a tormented old man. You solve puzzles and piece together an oppressive family tragedy bit by bit.

The Crow's Eye

Puzzles and brain teasers

An atmospheric first-person puzzle adventure set in an abandoned medical university, where you solve puzzles and uncover the disappearance of students and faculty two decades ago. It focuses on eerie tension rather than combat.

D

Dark, serious atmosphere

An early interactive horror movie from Warp: as Laura you explore a creepy hospital in first person, solving puzzles to uncover why your father went on a killing spree. Its pre-rendered CGI cutscenes and disturbing themes like cannibalism made it infamous.

Among the Innocent: A Stricken Tale

Puzzles and brain teasers

You explore an abandoned farm in South Africa from a first-person view, solving point-and-click-style puzzles to uncover a dark mystery.

Dark Fall 2: Lights Out

Puzzles and brain teasers

You explore a haunted lighthouse on Fetch Rock alone, solving tricky puzzles to uncover what happened to three vanished keepers. Slow-burning dread and ghostly storytelling rather than action make it a classic of point-and-click horror.